feat: Link-Taxonomie u2 - kb/entities/people, projects, kb/comparisons gelabelt
Files changed: - kb/comparisons/amd-pstate vs acpi-cpufreq.md - kb/concepts/RAG.md - kb/entities/people/Andrej Karpathy.md - kb/entities/people/E3DC GmbH.md - kb/entities/people/Rohit Gupta.md - kb/entities/people/Vannevar Bush.md - kb/entities/projects/BCDModule.md - kb/entities/projects/Chemenu.md - kb/entities/projects/andybalholm-edl.md - kb/entities/projects/goresponsiveness.md - kb/entities/projects/ha-core.md - kb/entities/projects/hacs-e3dc.md - kb/entities/projects/hacs-integration-blueprint.md - kb/entities/projects/kfchou/wiki-skills.md - kb/entities/projects/plugnburn-edl.md - kb/entities/projects/vanillaflava/wiki-skills-vanillaflava.md - kb/entities/projects/yugasun/llm-wiki-skills.md - kb/entities/tools/Agent Memory.md - kb/log.md - work/link-taxonomy-migration/README.md - work/link-taxonomy-migration/glossary.md
This commit is contained in:
@@ -60,3 +60,31 @@ Deferred edges for later units, discovered while processing systems:
|
||||
software (E3DC implements Modbus).
|
||||
- Two entities in the same wiki cited as parallel real-world examples of the same concept, with
|
||||
no sharper label fitting: `see-also` is correct and not a cop-out (Memex/Tolkien Gateway).
|
||||
- **Taxonomy gap, confirmed while processing u2 (people):** there is no "created by" / "authored"
|
||||
/ "extends the work of" label for a person-entity pointing at another entity or at a concept.
|
||||
`owns` covers a person being *accountable for* an entity going forward (used for `Vannevar
|
||||
Bush owns Memex`, `Rohit Gupta owns Agent Memory`, `E3DC GmbH owns E3DC`), but a one-time
|
||||
historical act of creating/originating a *concept* (Karpathy authoring the LLM Wiki Pattern,
|
||||
Bush originating Memex-the-idea) or of one person's work building on another's (Gupta extending
|
||||
Karpathy) has nothing in Realization or Lineage that is authorised for a person: those
|
||||
registers are concept-to-concept or concept-to-entity, never entity-to-entity or
|
||||
entity-to-concept for authorship. Resolved as `see-also` in every such case on Karpathy's,
|
||||
Gupta's and Bush's own pages, checked against every register first - not a stretch, a genuine
|
||||
gap. Worth proposing a label (`originates`/`authored-by`?) if this recurs in u3/u4.
|
||||
- **comparisons pages carry no `related:` field at all.** `types/comparison.md` declares only
|
||||
`entities` (`page_ref_fields: [entities]`) - unlabelled by the schema, like `sources:`. `xref
|
||||
add`/`xref remove` refuse on this type ("type does not declare a related: field"). The
|
||||
`compares-with` label from `kb/comparisons/COLLECTION.md`'s `outbound:` block is documentational
|
||||
only for this type: it is written into the `## Beziehungen` prose by hand (there is no marker
|
||||
region either), never into machine data. Confirmed on `amd-pstate vs acpi-cpufreq.md`.
|
||||
- A dependent-side project whose own page only names the platform vaguely ("Kernintegrationsbibliothek
|
||||
für E3DC-Systeme") while a specific downstream package (a HACS component, an automation
|
||||
blueprint) explicitly wraps it: assert `required-by` from the depended-upon project's page for
|
||||
each specific downstream package, mirroring `depends-on` asserted on each dependent's own page -
|
||||
the same genuine two-sided pair as `E3DC`/`ha-core` from u1, one level up the stack
|
||||
(`ha-core`/`hacs-e3dc`, `ha-core`/`hacs-integration-blueprint`).
|
||||
- An external, out-of-wiki reference project cited only as "look how someone else solved this" (a
|
||||
GitHub repo mentioned as a structural analogue, no functional dependency): `see-also` asserted
|
||||
from the external project's own page toward the project it inspired, not the reverse - matches
|
||||
"reads correctly from the source page" even though nothing here is a stretch, just weak by
|
||||
nature (`wiki-skills`, `wiki-skills-vanillaflava`, `llm-wiki-skills` -> `Chemenu`).
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user